Posted by Never mind all those Ashes Best XIs. Who would get into the far more hotly-contested 2019 Ashes Worst XI?
1. David Warner – 95 runs at 9.50
First name on our team sheet even if we weren’t starting at the top and working our way down. If Josh Hazlewood had made just one more run then no Australian would have averaged less than David Warner, which is very impressive indeed.
2. Jason Roy – 110 runs at 13.75
This was such a tough call. It was tempting to go for Marcus Harris, who made 58 runs at 9.66, but we’re picking an opener here and when opening Roy made 57 runs at 9.50. Just one run in it. Seems weird that Roy should edge out someone other than himself, but there you go.
3. Usman Khawaja – 122 runs at 20.33
Joe Root wasn’t far off for his 254 runs at 28.22 when batting at three, but Khawaja gets the nod for his edging-to-the-keeper masterclass. He did it five times on the trot before mixing things up with an edge to slip.
4. Joe Denly – 312 runs at 31.2
It seems England did have Denly and Roy the wrong way round. Denly averaged over 40 as opener, but when he batted in the middle order, he made 147 runs at 24.50 and looked like a guy who’d sneaked his way into a limited overs squad off the back of some part-time leg-spin and had then been allowed to hang around with the Test squad after missing his train. Denly also conceded 87 runs in 21 overs without taking a wicket, which is very handy contribution to a Worst XI.
5. Jonny Bairstow – 214 runs at 23.77
Bairstow kept very well, so let’s play him as a specialist batsman. The only danger here is that it’ll annoy him enough that he hits one of his patented point-proving hundreds.
6. Jos Buttler – 247 runs at 24.7
There are currently calls for Bairstow to surrender the gloves to Buttler and concentrate on batting because (a) there always are, and (b) he didn’t make any runs. This rather overlooks the fact that Buttler didn’t make many more and also made 41 of them while batting at eight.
7. Tim Paine – 180 runs at 20.00
In a hotly contested field, Tim Paine was the least productive wicketkeeper-batsman. He also admits that he can’t read pitches and can’t do reviews either, so he can be captain.
8. Ben Stokes – 8 wickets at 45.25
Picked purely as a bowler. Stokes delivered one titanic spell at Headingley, but in a series where wickets were being handed out like those cartoon character cards they were doing at Sainsbury’s over the summer, he collected impressively few. Stokes may actually have suffered from watching his colleagues dismiss the top order before being invited to ‘make something happen’ once Steve Smith was well set.
9. Moeen Ali – 3 wickets at 57.33 and four runs at 2.00
Moeen played one match. That wouldn’t normally provide enough evidence to justify selection for a Worst XI, but somehow Moeen made his case unarguable, despite taking three wickets. The leave to Nathan Lyon was enough on its own, really.
10. James Pattinson – 5 wickets at 33.40
Amid much talk about how amazing and terrifying he is, James Pattinson took five wickets in two Tests against this England batting line-up.
11. Peter Siddle – 7 wickets at 42.14
Bowled pretty effectively one innings and pretty ineffectively the next. Edges out Craig Overton, who only had the one Test to show us what he couldn’t do.
King Cricket is a largely crowdfunded website. Thanks again to everyone who supports us via Patreon because your contributions help buy us the time to write features like this. If you’d like to chip in a quid or the price of a pint each month to help support the site, you can do so via our Patreon page.
Steve Smith looked like a fish out of water. By which I mean that he flapped around uncoordinatedly with none of his body parts seemingly under the control of his head. And he looks like a fish.
As for the rest of your so-called list, it’s excellent. I especially like how Ben “The Nation’s Hero” Stokes has got on it. This is the absolute truth of all the scariest players – that their careers are nowhere near as impressive as their highlights. Botham – averaged 33 with the bat and 28 (not bad) with the ball. Flintoff – 32 and 33 respectively. Brett Lee – remember how he tore into the English and caused panic in the ranks? He averaged over 40 with the ball in Ashes series. Shane Warne? OK, Shane Warne was both scary and effective, but that in no way diminishes my point.
What was my point, can anyone remember? Oh yeh, that’s it. Lay off our Ben (The Nation’s Victim of Media Oppression). Bloody journalists, eh Ged?
I’m confused. You say ‘journalists’, but appear to be referring to the Sun?
Indeed, Bert. The fourth estate is a veritable fifth column these days.
My advice to you is to keep away from such fiends. Especially after dark.
Bound for the sixth circle of Hell
It shows the quality of the sides, or lack there of I suppose, that you couldn’t find space for Bancroft, Head, Woakes or Overton!
Nearly put Overton in at three for his nightwatchman effort, but others produced a greater weight of rubbishness.
I spy a problem with this side.
It’s all very well with including Stokes as a bowler; but as yet Maj has said on occasion, one of the delightful things about cricket is that everyone has to bat, including the bowlers who are eminently ill-suited to. Stokes is not eminently ill-suited to. Considering that Stokes has previous batting with the tail, he may accomplish even more ludicrous feats of batting coming in at 8.
Alternatively, go the whole hog and play Smith as a leggie at 11.
We are aware we would need to find a way to dissuade him from batting properly.
The problem with your team is that it contains a massive quantity of dueness. It is literally player after player who HAS left a considerable amount in the locker, and has most certainly NOT left it on the park.
If half these players found a quarter of what they’ve still got to offer, they’d be absolutely unstoppable. And once they’d done that, the simple harmonic momentum of sport would catapult them all the way to Successville.
Meanwhile, the team of their counterparts could not possibly play as well as they have, and would therefore be plagued by what I like to call “Winner’s Syndrome”, the result of which is Death Wish 3.
We can resolve this.
2019 Ashes
WorstDue XI.Travis Head is extremely stiff to miss out on selection, Buttler didn’t have a great series but he made a few runs here and there while people around him struggled. Head pretty much exclusively batted with Smith making a hundred at the other end and was still pants.