Who’s your favourite Mitch? And who’s your least favourite?

Posted by
< 1 minute read

Not much is happening in the cricket at the minute, so we might as well busy ourselves tackling the difficult philosophical questions. If three Mitches play cricket for Australia, is it possible to have a favourite?

For us, this is the order in which we’d place them – best at the top.

  1. Mitchell Starc
  2. Mitchell Johnson
  3. Mitchell Marsh

If we try and explain our reasoning, it seems our preference is largely based on cricketing reasons, which is something of a surprise. In short, we feel that Starc ‘deserves’ success, while Marsh doesn’t.

We remember in the early days of Jason Gillespie’s career, Steve Waugh (or possibly even Mark Taylor) tried to embiggen him before an Ashes series by saying he was the best bowler in the world. It was bollocks, obviously – he was only the third-best bowler in the team – but the captain did at least put forward a reasoned argument.

He said that Gillespie was the perfect fast bowler. He said he was tall, bowled 90-odd mph and swung it both ways, all of which was true at the time. We kind of feel the same about Mitchell Starc, only he’s also a left-armer. We figure if a player has all of those qualities, he should be successful otherwise much of what we believe about cricket is wrong.

As for Marsh, he’s a medium-pacer and an Aussie all-rounder. If they prove effective, it again calls into question much of what we believe about cricket.

On the plus side, there’s a Twitter account about Mitch Marsh that we find funny largely on the grounds that we don’t get it. Merchell Mersh communicates with weird neanderthal vowel sounds and that’s pretty much the joke.

We generally just try and avoid thinking about Mitchell Johnson.

4 comments

  1. Here is my are my rationale, together with my scores/ratings/rankings. It is quite complex, but I hope my summary below does justice to some deep thinking on this important matter.

    Mitchell Starc – indifferent – 3rd equal.
    Mitchell Johnson – indifferent – 3rd equal.
    Mitchell Marsh – indifferent – 3rd equal.

  2. I would plump for the Michelin man (geddit), Glasgow’s Mitchell library and newsreader and sometime BBC royal correspondent, Nicholas Mitchell. I’m not thinking about cricket at the moment.

Comments are closed.